games

  • terraria
  • craft the world
  • graveyard keeper
  • stardew valley
  • banished
  • deiland
  • my time at portia
  • battle chasers

difficulty/annoyance of fishing vs value gained

Game Difficulty Value Complexity Appeal Ignorable
Terraria low
Craft the World low
Graveyard Keeper ridiculous
Stardew Valley middling with a progression curve
Banished low
Deiland medium
My Time at Portia don’t know
Battle Chasers medium
  • terraria: difficulty: low value: high complexity: low appeal: yes, in its simplicity ignorable: no, rare fishing-only equipment and potion materials
  • craft the world: difficulty: low value: medium complexity: low appeal: sure? the dwarves seem to enjoy it ignorable: yes, can buy fish
  • graveyard keeper: difficulty: ridiculous value: none complexity: high appeal: high complexity is a turnoff, but it looks really well thought-out ignorable: yes, can buy fish
  • stardew valley: difficulty: middling with a progression curve value: medium complexity: medium appeal: moderate ignorable: maybe? fish are harder to buy and their availability is random; some are needed for completing the game
  • banished: difficulty: low value: medium complexity: low appeal: your citizens are healthier with food variety and you can drive them harder, mwuahaha ignorable: yes, can buy fish
  • deiland: difficulty: medium value: low complexity: low appeal: the system is uncessecarily twitch-difficult with random contextual button pushes. I’m too old for that crap. ignorable: maybe
  • my time at portia: difficulty: don’t know value: none complexity: don’t know appeal: rather punch llamas ignorable: yes, can buy fish
  • battle chasers: difficulty: medium value: medium complexity: medium appeal: low, because you have to take breaks from smashing faces, and the dungeons are already tedious enough ignorable: maybe not, something about upgrades

how nice the fishing system is

how complex the fishing system is

whether the fishing system can be completely ignored, while still accomplishing all of the main objectives of the game